Possibly because it takes place in a magic world of the s and not the modern — sort of — days. If somebody wants to read mainly about a love story, Twilight is a better choice than Harry Potter. Yes, there are romances in the Harry Potter world as well but they're a small part of a much bigger mix. Twilight focuses on the romantic relationships between its characters, and while not everybody may like Bella and Edward together , there are some other interesting couples, such as Alice and Jasper or Esme and Carlisle.
It's true that Bella might be relatable for many young readers who also feel they're in no way special. But she's way too dependent on Edward and her behavior when Edward temporarily dumps her is far from healthy. Harry Potter, on the other hand, has plenty of amazing inspirational strong female heroines. There's Hermione, of course, and Ginny , who may not have gotten much love and space in the films, but she's a total badass in the books.
And neither of them let their whole lives revolve around their guys. Both Harry Potter and Twilight belong to the fantasy genre but only Harry Potter properly uses all the genre offers it and can truly be called imaginative. Twilight also includes some original elements but it's very much connected to the everyday world.
Harry Potter creates a brand new world with its own set of rules and details, though, and it's fascinating to discover it as people keep on reading or watching. Sometimes it's also about the quantity, not just the quality. Download Now Download to read offline and view in fullscreen. Download Now Download Download to read offline. Arati Maheta Follow. English teacher. Female Characters in films with reference to Hamlet, A scarlet letter, Harry Feminism in waiting for barbarians. Harry potter books.
Harry Potter Powerpoint. Internet as media. Rtpptsclp Rtppt 9 w4g. Rt ppt p Related Books Free with a 30 day trial from Scribd. Dry: A Memoir Augusten Burroughs. Related Audiobooks Free with a 30 day trial from Scribd. Empath Up! Compare them with Ludo Bagman, the hilarious ex-athlete with a gambling problem, or Dobby, a helpful house elf who rejects society's enslavement of his race and longs for freedom.
Okay, Renesmee was a huge surprise considering we were led to believe vampires couldn't have babies. Other than that, the series is pretty predictable.
We all knew Bella would end up with Edward from the first book. A seemingly hateful professor, who was once Death Eater, switching sides for the woman he's loved since childhood and remaining a double agent until he himself is double crossed?! Aside from turning into a vampire, Bella is pretty much the same girl from the beginning of the series. Now, it's not really fair to judge Harry and Bella by the same standards since Harry obviously grows up a ton from 11 to But the other Harry Potter characters experience so much development, too!
Remus grows to accept his werewolf self enough to find happiness in his marriage, Regulus dies in an attempt to thwart the Dark Lord, and even Percy abandons his Ministry-loving ways to reunite with his family. We don't get such satisfying character arcs from Twilight minor characters.
Bella mentions Edward's beauty like, every other page. We get it. He's gorgeous. In comparison, Harry thinks Ginny is pretty, sure, but she's also fierce, smart, and spirited.
Most importantly, she and Harry really get each other. When Harry breaks up with her to pursue the Horcruxes, she gets that it's for a "stupid, noble reason. Twilight is for sure a fun read, and I've gone back to enjoy the series again several times. The monster tells Victor this before the wedding as a warning. Open Document. Essay Sample Check Writing Quality.
Harry Potter and Twilight are both wildly popular book series. Harry Potter written by J. Rowling follows a young wizard through his discovery of his wizardry, education in magic, and avenging the death of his parents.
Twilight written by Stephanie Meyers is about a teenaged girl who falls in love with a boy from school only to find out he is a vampire. Both books were developed into films. Harry Potter not only has a deeper, more interesting plot, but also teaches valuable morals and life lessons. Twilight begins when a young girl named Bella Swan moves to Forks, Washington to live with her father. Awkward and …show more content… The few times it is actually brought up, Twilight conveys friendship as a relatively useless idea.
She has no real friends that she can trust aside from Edward and is practically useless in his absence. The friends Bella makes in the first movie make very few appearances in any of the sequels and play little to no role in her life. Each time one of the trio finds themselves in a predicament, the other two come to their aid and refuse to abandon each …show more content… Bella is forced to decide between Edward and her mortality- both decisions could be considered brave.
Of course if she stays with Edward she has to leave behind her family and friends, constantly moving to remain undetected by those around her. This seems to be the braver choice, however, leaving Edward would mean leaving the love of her life. Although, it can be argued that this relationship was anything but healthy.
0コメント